Introduction In today’s ever-present and ever-expanding financial markets, there are many forms of trading undertaken by individuals and institutions to gain an advantageous position or financial outcome. One of those forms of trading is known as proprietary trading, or "prop trading," which occurs when a trading desk at a financial institution, brokerage firm, investment bank, hedge fund. or other liquidity source uses the firm's capital and balance sheet to conduct self-promoting financial transactions[1]. [1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/proprietarytrading.asp 1. How is propriety trading different from regular trading? Traders traditionally make their money through a range of fees from clients, primarily a ‘brokerage fee’ which is for the pleasure of the institution facilitating the trade on behalf of the client. The second is what is known as the “spread”. In stock trading, this is the difference between the current bid and ask prices for a stock (the bid/ask or bid/offer spread). In futures trading, this is the price difference between delivery months for the same commodity or asset. In bond trading, it is the difference between yields of bonds with similar quality and different maturities, or of different quality and the same maturity. In underwriting, it is the difference between what the issuer receives from the underwriter and what the underwriter receives from the public (underwriting spread).[1] Therefore, as the above definition from the Financial Times suggests, it is the difference between whatever financial instrument costs to acquire for the broker or institution and what they on-sell it to the client for. Proprietary trading test differs in that it uses the internal, institutional cash to profit from opportunities in the marketplace, without clients being involved. 2. Are there any benefits to clients of institutions who conduct proprietary trading? However, it must be noted before we move too far forward into the benefits of proprietary trading, that it is seen as a risky form of trading, albeit one of the most profitable operations of a commercial orinvestment bank. During the financial crisis of 2008, prop traders and hedge funds were among the firms that were scrutinized for causing the crisis[1] in the first place. When it comes to the specific benefits for the clients of the institutions that engage in proprietary trading, there are a number of key qualities in favour of this style of trading which are outlined below: Proprietary trading allows a financial institution to become an influential market maker by providing liquidity on specific security or group of securities.[2] In reality, the client benefits are only that the banks and institutions that conduct proprietary trading, in theory, should be more liquid, and have access to assets in potential markets which don’t favour their client's position. The means that trader can be in a state to assist them to buy or sell the asset as they require, not to mention being a market ‘maker’ or influencer’ which could further assist their client's position. It is no secret that proprietary trading has the primary goal of making money for its institution. [1] https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/trading-investing/proprietary-trading/ [2] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/proprietarytrading.asp 3. The Volcker Rule Created in the aftermath of the 2008 Global Financial Crisis and named after former US Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker, the Volcker Rule disallows short-term proprietary trading of securities, derivatives, commodity futures and options on these instruments for banks’ own accounts under the premise that these activities do not benefit banks’ customers. In other words, banks cannot use their own funds to make these types of investments to increase their profits. The purpose is to discourage banks from taking too much risk[1]. Although the Volcker Rule in relation to proprietary trading specifically is a US Federal law and not applicable within Australia, it sets the tone for regulation of the industry in not only the wake of the GFC, in which over $14 trillion was wiped from the global economy. On a global level, it was realised that banks in many counties, not only the USA were not managing their levels of risk. In response, the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision revised its international framework of regulatory standards to improve the resilience of the global financial system. The revised framework increased capital requirements and introduced minimum liquidity standards.[2] In Australia specifically, the 2014 Financial System Inquiry made a number of recommendations to strengthen the Australian financial system. In addition, APRA implemented a range of changes to the amount of capital and liquidity that a bank needed to hold. This has led to the total capital ratio of the Australian banking system has risen by 3¾ percentage points since the start of 2008, and currently stands at 14¼ per cent[3]. By doing this, the changes meant that the banks are in a stronger position to weather any financial storm that may occur. Coupled with the Australian bank response to the 2018 Royal Commission into the Banking and Insurance sectors has now seen increases in liquidity but contractions in the retail finance offerings that receive approval in terms – particularly in terms of residential and small business loans. For example, an analysis of more than 30,000 mortgages from online broker Lendi has found approval times have more than doubled for investors over the past 18 months while the wait time for owner-occupiers has increased by more than 50 per cent as the banks demand more information from borrowers.[4] [1] https://www.cfainstitute.org/en/advocacy/issues/volcker-rule [2] https://www.rba.gov.au/publications/bulletin/2017/jun/5.html [3] https://www.rba.gov.au/publications/bulletin/2017/jun/5.html 4. A final word on propriety trading When trading with client’s money, in a fund or as part of a managed investment scheme, although the risks are minimised, in large part the profits (and losses) are enjoyed by the client, while the firm who has done the majority of the work, research and applied their expertise only enjoy their fee as well as the spread charged to the client. Propriety trading allows firms to wave the fees, not apply the spread to the trade as well as the benefit from all the in-house knowledge, skills and expertise to profiteer from and add to the bottom line. There are the risks that institutions around the world where the Volcker rule does not apply that banks will not apply sufficient rules and regulations around propriety trading which could, in theory – and in practice – collapse companies and economies around the world should they not be managed efficiently. From the credit default swaps of the 2008 financial crisis, through to mortgage-backed securities of today, there is a range of financial instruments –, especially derivatives - that promote a winner takes all mentality that banks simply should avoid to stave off a future global financial crisis. Only in the case of unethical behaviour in which a firm takes a position against that of a fund under their management – for reasons not as a hedge for a fund itself – or bets against the position taken by the fund should an investor be affected. As an investor, it is important to understand about proprietary trading and its purpose, however, unless you have involved in fund management yourself, as a retail investor you will have little contact with the features, advantages and benefits of proprietary trading. 1. Schedule an appointment (Conference Call) with an Investment Manager 2. Submit a Managed Discretionary Account (MDA) application with Walker Capital Australia. 3. Open a trading account with the Walker Capital Australia’s executing broker. 4. Select from our range of investment strategies and choose your asset allocation between the choices of accounts. 5. Once all accounts are opened, and funds have been chosen, our team gets to work and begins trading.Unlike regular traders at your financial institution, brokerage firm, investment bank, hedge fund or an associated institution, the propriety trading desk is run independently to that which the client's institution serves, and is set up to benefit the institution first and foremost.
Investment Risk Profiler wondering what type of investor you really are?
Prop trading is focused on the institution itself profiting from the skills and expertise of the traders
Although proprietary or “prop” trading is primarily focused on the institution itself and profiteering from the skills and expertise of the proprietary trading desk traders, it also has several key underlying benefits for the retail clients of the firms that undertake proprietary trading.
It is hard to go into too much detail about proprietary trading without first discussing the Volcker Rule.
The future of the sector has changed dramatically and is undoubtedly set for more change, largely in the name of protecting consumer’s interests.
Insiders Guide to Trading and Investment Analysis.
Propriety trading is a highly profitable and internal way for firms to increase their market cap. Through trading in stocks, bonds, commodities, bonds, currencies, derivatives using a firm’s money rather than clients allows businesses to make profits for itself, providing financial firms with a strong financial advantage.
Proprietary trading does not affect retail investors, as it is the firm investing its own money.
Try our M
Looking to get started in Investing:
We welcome you to give our team a call to discuss your investment goals and objectives.
You can call Walker Capital Australia on +61 2 8076 2210, and we’ll see how we can help you achieve your investment goals.
FAQs
How is propriety trading different to regular trading | Walker Capital? ›
Hedge funds invest in the financial markets using their clients' money. They are paid to generate gains on these investments. Proprietary traders use their firm's own money to invest in the financial markets, and they retain 100% of the returns generated.
How is prop trading different from regular trading? ›Prop firms specialize in trading strategies and financial instruments such as equities, commodities, or options. On the other hand, traditional trading pertains to traders who trade using their capital. These traders can be individuals operating from home or professionals working in institutions or hedge funds.
What is the difference between prop trading and physical trading? ›Proprietary trading will involve higher risk levels because of the speculation of the financial market. Gains and losses can be significant due to the amount of leverage investors use. Physical trading is less risky mostly due to the supply and demand of the commodities. Price fluctuations can still pose a challenge.
What is the difference between prop trading and retail trading? ›The key difference between retail trading and proprietary trading is that a retail trader trades with their own funds, while a prop trader trades with the funds of a company which specifically hired such a person to capitalize on the firm's assets and make even more money.
What is the difference between prop trading and institutional trading? ›Capital Source and Risk: The primary distinction lies in the source of capital and risk exposure. Prop traders use the firm's capital and share profits with the firm, while institutional traders manage external funds and follow specific investment mandates.
Why is proprietary trading bad? ›Personal Risk: One of the significant drawbacks of prop trading is the potential personal financial risk. If a trader doesn't perform well, they may lose their deposit, and in some cases, their job. Loss Limitations: Prop firms often implement daily loss limits to protect their capital.
How stressful is prop trading? ›Prop trading can be highly stressful due to the fast-paced nature of markets and the pressure to make split-second decisions. Working in the financial markets as a prop trader comes with a series of demanding hurdles. Such traders face an environment filled with: Intense rivalry.
Do banks still do prop trading? ›Since the 2008 financial crisis, that has become somewhat less true. In the US, proprietary trading, as a business for big banks, has been more or less outlawed for a decade by the Volcker Rule.
Why do prop traders make so much money? ›Commissions: Prop trading firms often charge commissions on trades made by their traders. These commissions can range from a few dollars to hundreds or even thousands of dollars per trade, depending on the size and complexity of the transaction. This is one of the primary sources of income for prop trading firms.
What is the risk of prop trading? ›Profits from trades are generally divided between the firm and the prop trader; however, the risk distribution is asymmetric. This means that in the event of a loss, the trader bears 100% of the losses, while they don't receive 100% of the profits.
Is prop trading illegal? ›
§ 255.3 Prohibition on proprietary trading. (a) Prohibition. Except as otherwise provided in this subpart, a banking entity may not engage in proprietary trading. Proprietary trading means engaging as principal for the trading account of the banking entity in any purchase or sale of one or more financial instruments.
What do proprietary traders do? ›Proprietary Trading (Prop Trading) occurs when a bank or firm trades stocks, derivatives, bonds, commodities, or other financial instruments in its own account, using its own money instead of using clients' money.
What is considered proprietary trading? ›Proprietary trading, or “prop trading,” occurs when a financial firm or commercial bank uses its own money — and not that of its clients — to trade stocks, bonds, mutual funds or other securities. In other words, the firm puts up their own funds to earn a profit instead of relying on client fees and commissions.
What is proprietary trading under the Volcker Rule? ›The Volcker rule prohibits banks from engaging in proprietary trading activities. Proprietary trading is defined by the rule as a bank serving as a principal of a trading account in buying or selling a financial instrument.
What are the proprietary trading strategies? ›Prop trading strategies are employed by these institutions to generate profits through speculative trades using their own capital. These strategies are designed to take advantage of short-term market inefficiencies and price discrepancies to maximize profits.
Is trading for a prop firm worth it? ›Prop firms are an excellent source of accessing further capital to increase profit potential. Passing a prop firm's evaluation means reaching a profit target while staying within its risk management rules. Prop firms require traders to use their brokers, which can be positive or negative depending on the broker.
What are the advantages of trading with a prop firm? ›Access to Capital: One of the most significant advantages of joining a prop trading firm is the access to the company's capital. Traders can leverage the firm's funds, which allows them to take larger trading positions than they could afford with their own capital. This can potentially lead to higher profits.
Is prop trading a good idea? ›While prop trading is one of the most profitable opportunities, it is affected by asymmetric risk. This means that the profit-sharing ratio may be from 75% to 90%, but you bear 100% of the risk of your trades. When becoming a prop trader, you often need to deposit an amount of money known as your risk contribution.
Is it good to trade with prop firms? ›Low Capital Risk
One of the most appealing aspects of prop trading is the minimal risk it imposes on personal capital. When trading with a reputable prop firm like SurgeTrader, traders are safeguarded from major financial losses. The only capital at stake is the one-time SurgeTrader Audition fee.